The Double Illusion of Choice: The Conditioning That Keeps Us Trapped
Choice is one of the most powerful things a person can have. It shapes our lives, our identities, and our futures. We often hear phrases like “You always have a choice” or “Life is what you make of it,” as if choosing is something we can do freely, without external influence. But what if the choices we think we have aren’t as free as they seem? What if, for most of our lives, we’ve been conditioned into a double illusion - one that makes us feel like we have no choice at all, while simultaneously restricting the choices we think we do have?
From the moment we’re born, we are shaped by the world around us. Our families, our schools, our cultures, and our societies mould us, often without us realising it. We are taught rules - both spoken and unspoken - about what is expected of us, what is right and wrong, and how we should move through life. These rules are often presented as absolute truths rather than perspectives shaped by history, culture, and power constructs. As children, we don’t question them. We absorb them. We internalise them. And over time, they shape how we see ourselves and our place in the world.
The first illusion of choice begins here: the idea that we don’t really have a choice at all. This conditioning can be incredibly subtle. It starts with small things - what we are allowed to wear, how we are expected to behave, what emotions are acceptable to express. A child learns quickly that certain behaviours lead to praise while others lead to punishment or disapproval. A girl who is loud and assertive may be told she is "bossy," while a boy who cries easily may be told to "toughen up." A child who questions authority may be labelled as "difficult" rather than curious. The message is clear: follow the rules, fit into the mould, don’t make things difficult. As we grow older, this belief solidifies. We begin to feel as though our lives are predetermined. We are told that certain paths lead to success and others lead to failure. We are given a script - go to school, get a stable job, settle down, be responsible. For some, this path might feel aligned, but for many, it feels suffocating. The idea that we must follow a specific trajectory, without deviation, strips us of the confidence to choose for ourselves. Even when alternatives exist, they often feel risky or unrealistic because we have been conditioned to believe that stepping off the expected path is dangerous.
This belief - that we don’t really have a choice - can be paralysing. It creates a sense of helplessness that seeps into every aspect of life. If you feel like you don’t have real choices, you stop actively shaping your own life. You settle. You tell yourself that things are just the way they are. You stay in unfulfilling jobs or relationships because the alternative feels too uncertain. You silence parts of yourself to fit in because standing out feels unsafe. The illusion that you have no real control over your life can lead to deep levels of anxiety, a feeling of powerlessness, and even depression. After all, if you don’t believe you have choices, how can you ever feel empowered?
But just when we think we’ve made peace with the idea that we don’t have a choice, society presents us with the second illusion: the illusion that we do have choices, but only from a pre-approved set of options. This illusion is even more deceptive because it makes us believe we are in control when, in reality, we are simply choosing from paths that have already been dictated for us.
Take, for example, career paths. We are told to follow our dreams, but only as long as those dreams fit within the acceptable framework of success. A career in medicine or law is applauded, but a career in art or philosophy is often met with scepticism. Follow the standard, meet someone, get married, have babies etc. We are given the illusion of freedom, but the moment we choose something unconventional; we are met with resistance - questions, doubt, shame, guilt, warnings about financial security or wasted potential. The choices exist, but they are not truly free; they are weighted, shaped by cultural expectations and external pressures. This illusion extends far beyond careers. It affects how we define success, what relationships we pursue, how we express ourselves, and even how we see morality. We are told that we can choose who we want to be, but only within a narrow range of identities that fit within societal norms. We are encouraged to think for ourselves, but when our thinking challenges the conditions put in place, we are dismissed, shamed, or silenced. We are given “choices” in politics, in social settings, in belief systems, but these choices are often just variations of the same fundamental constructs.
The result of this double illusion is a profound disconnect. On the one hand, we feel powerless, believing that we have no real control over our lives. On the other hand, we feel trapped, forced to pick from a set of predefined options that don’t always align with who we really are. This tension leaves many people feeling lost, lonely, and stuck in a cycle where they either resign themselves to their circumstances or chase choices that never fully feel like their own.
The Weight of the Illusion: How It Undermines Self-Trust and Fuels Anxiety
The illusion of choice doesn’t just shape the paths we take - it shapes how we see ourselves. It gets under our skin, embedding itself so deeply into our thinking that it becomes second nature. It affects the way we make decisions, the way we handle uncertainty, the way we trust - or fail to trust - in ourselves and others. And over time, this conditioning doesn’t just limit the choices we make, it starts to erode something even more fundamental: our ability to believe in our own judgment. When you are raised to believe that you don’t really have a choice, it’s easy to feel powerless. If you’ve spent your life being told that things "just are the way they are," that certain things must be done because "that’s how it’s always been," or that straying too far from the norm is risky, then the idea of making your own choices can feel overwhelming. Even when you are presented with options, they don’t feel like true choices - they feel like a test, like a trap, like something you could get wrong. And that fear of getting it wrong starts to chip away at self-trust.
One of the biggest casualties of this illusion is confidence. When you don’t feel like your choices are truly yours, it’s hard to trust yourself to make the right ones. Even small decisions become loaded with doubt. Should I take this job? Should I stay in this relationship? Should I speak up about something that doesn’t sit right with me? Instead of approaching these questions with clarity, there’s hesitation, self-doubt, a creeping anxiety that makes every choice feel like a potential mistake. Because when you’ve been conditioned to believe that you don’t really have control, decision-making stops being an act of empowerment and starts feeling like a risk you don’t know how to take. This kind of uncertainty can be paralysing. It leaves you second-guessing yourself constantly, replaying decisions in your mind long after they’ve been made, wondering if you should have done something differently. Even when a choice turns out fine, the fear remains: What if next time I mess it up? What if I make the wrong call? What if I disappoint someone?The irony is that this fear often prevents people from making choices at all, leaving them stuck in situations that don’t serve them simply because the idea of making a change feels too overwhelming.
And then there’s the other side of it - the illusion that we do have choices, but only the ones that society approves of. This, too, can be deeply damaging to self-trust. Because when you are given a limited set of options, none of which fully align with who you are, it creates a constant sense of unease. You might be able to choose between career paths, but if none of them reflect what you actually want, then is it really a choice? You might be able to choose how you express yourself, but if stepping outside certain expectations invites criticism or exclusion, then is it really freedom?
This disconnect - between what we actually want and what we feel we are "allowed" to choose - creates a kind of inner friction. You might go along with what’s expected of you because it feels safer, because it seems like the right thing to do. But deep down, something doesn’t sit right. There’s a quiet discomfort, a sense that you are living someone else’s life rather than your own. And when you start to feel that way but don’t know what to do about it, it can turn into something heavier - self-doubt, frustration, and again even depression.
Depression often thrives in spaces where people feel powerless. When you don’t feel like your choices are truly yours, when you feel like your life is something happening to you rather than something you are actively shaping, it’s easy to feel stuck. There’s a loss of agency, a sense of helplessness that can be incredibly difficult to shake. If every decision feels dictated by external forces, then what is there to look forward to? If you don’t trust yourself to make the "right" choice, then why even try?
Anxiety, too, feeds off this illusion. When you don’t trust yourself, everything feels like a potential threat. Even small choices become overwhelming because they feel loaded with the fear of failure or rejection. You might overthink, analyse every possible outcome, seek reassurance from others instead of listening to your own instincts. And the more you rely on external validation, the more disconnected you become from your own voice.
It’s not just about the big, life-altering choices - it’s about the small, everyday ones as well. The way you hesitate before speaking your mind because you’re worried about how it will be received. The way you suppress parts of yourself to fit in, because stepping outside the lines feels too risky. The way you default to what is expected, even when it doesn’t feel right, because the alternative feels too scary.
Reclaiming Our Power: Recognising That We Always Have a Choice
When we’ve spent so much of our lives believing that choice is either non-existent or severely limited, the idea that we actually do have choice can feel radical. It can also feel uncomfortable. If we have been conditioned to believe that our paths are set for us - by our upbringing, by societal expectations, by external pressures - then reclaiming our ability to choose can feel unfamiliar, even intimidating. After all, if we suddenly acknowledge that we have power over our own decisions, that means we are responsible for them too right? And that responsibility can be daunting, especially if we’ve spent years thinking we had no control.
But here’s the thing: we always have a choice. Even in situations where our external options seem limited, even in circumstances where change feels impossible, we still have the ability to choose - if nothing else, we can choose our perspective, our response, and the meaning we assign to our experiences. This shift in mindset doesn’t erase hardship or difficulty, but it does give us back our agency. It allows us to move from feeling powerless to feeling like active participants in our own lives. And that change, even if it starts in the smallest of ways, is where real transformation begins. For many people, the idea of choice feels tied to big, life-altering decisions - leaving a relationship, quitting a job, moving to a new place. But choice exists in the everyday moments too. It exists in the way we speak to ourselves, in the way we approach challenges, in the way we interpret the events that shape us. It exists in the way we decide to respond to fear, to setbacks, to unknowns. Sometimes, reclaiming choice doesn’t mean changing our external circumstances at all. It means shifting our mindset from ‘I have to’ to ‘I choose to.’ That shift, though subtle, is incredibly powerful.
Think about the difference between these two statements:
‘I have to stay in this job because I need financial security.’
‘I choose to stay in this job right now because financial security is important to me.’
The external reality in both cases is the same - the job remains. But the internal perspective is completely different. In the first case, there is no sense of agency; it feels like an obligation, a trap, a situation that is being imposed upon you. In the second case, there is ownership, a conscious decision to prioritise what is important to you at this moment. Even if the action remains the same, the way you experience it shifts. Instead of feeling powerless, you feel like you are making an intentional choice. This doesn’t mean that every situation will feel good or that all choices will be easy. Sometimes, the only choices available feel like different shades of difficult. But even then, the simple act of recognising that you are choosing - rather than being forced - can change the way you feel about your circumstances. It reminds you that you are not just a passive observer in your own life. You are the one making the decisions, even when those decisions are tough.
Reclaiming choice also means letting go of the belief that there is always a right and wrong decision. This is one of the biggest reasons people struggle with decision-making - because they are terrified of making the wrong choice. But what if there is no single "correct" path? What if every choice we make, even the ones that don’t go as planned, is simply an opportunity to learn, to grow, to adjust? When we stop seeing choices as permanent, high-stakes, make-or-break moments, we allow ourselves the freedom to experiment, to try, to fail, and to try again.
And perhaps most importantly, reclaiming choice is about self-trust. It’s about believing that no matter what happens, you will be able to handle the outcome. One of the biggest reasons we hesitate to make choices is because we don’t trust ourselves to navigate uncertainty. We question our own resilience, our ability to adapt, our capacity to deal with things if they don’t go as expected. But the truth is, you have already survived everything that has ever happened to you. You have faced challenges, made difficult decisions, and come out the other side. You have already proven to yourself, time and time again, that you are capable.
When you start to recognise that you always have a choice, even if it’s simply the choice to shift your perspective, you begin to rebuild that trust in yourself. You start to feel more aligned with your decisions, because they are coming from a place of intention rather than obligation. You begin to see yourself not as someone who is stuck, but as someone who is actively shaping their own life.
So how do we begin to integrate this mindset shift into our daily lives? It starts with small, conscious decisions. The next time you feel yourself saying I have to about something, pause and reframe it as I choose to. See how it feels. Notice the difference in energy when you step into a place of agency rather than obligation. Pay attention to the choices you make each day - what you eat, how you spend your time, how you speak to yourself. Recognise that even in moments of limitation, you still have power over the way you engage with your life.
And perhaps most importantly, be kind to yourself in this process. Breaking free from the illusion of choice takes time. It requires unlearning patterns that have been reinforced for years, maybe even decades, but with every small moment of conscious choice, you take a step closer to personal freedom.
Because at the end of the day, real power isn’t about having unlimited choices. It’s about recognising the choices you do have and embracing them fully. It’s about stepping into the role of creator in your own life rather than just following the script you were given. And that kind of power? That’s where transformation begins.
Comments